Skip to main content
First Nations & Māori Governance

The role of outsourcing in Indigenous affairs

A research brief examining how outsourcing in Indigenous affairs affects self-determination, Indigenous expertise and community control.

Ariel Landscape view of dirt road in Northern Territory Australia
First Nations & Māori Governance
The role of outsourcing in Indigenous affairs
  • Date: 17 Nov 2026

This research brief was published through ANZSOG's The Bridge newsletter, which connects academic research with public sector practice. It provides a concise summary of a piece of research relevant to public sector professionals. 

A paper in the Australian Journal of Public Administration explores how Indigenous Peoples’ right to self-determination is undermined through government outsourcing processes. These processes reflect settler colonial interpretations of independence and efficiency, which can deny First Peoples authority over their own futures.

The paper argues that outsourcing policy research and advice enables ‘expertise stripping’, moving the governance of Indigenous affairs even further away from Indigenous Peoples. This can alienate Indigenous Peoples from their ancestral lands and invalidate Indigenous policy expertise.

The history of Indigenous affairs in Australia

Tacit understandings of the relations between First Peoples and the colony of New South Wales were formalised with the concept of terra nullius. Unlike other colonies in Aotearoa New Zealand, Canada and the United States, the British did not engage with Indigenous Peoples in Australia as First Nations. Government responsibility for Indigenous Peoples’ citizenship rights has variously relied on narratives of benevolence, patriarchy or crisis.

The processes through which such responsibilities are enacted have evolved over time. Although the Commonwealth exercised direct administrative control over Indigenous Affairs in the Northern Territory from 1911 to 1978, it was not until the 1967 Referendum that it formally received the power to make laws for Indigenous Australians across the continent. Consequently, jurisdictional roles and funding responsibilities overlap and have always been unclear.

Woven through different policy eras are narratives that seek to explain the relationship between First Peoples and the state:

  • The Colonisation era is a story of the takeover of the continent.

  • The Protection era sees the government assuming responsibility for First Peoples and rendering Indigenous governance practices and claims to land redundant.

By the time Indigenous activism drives a shift towards self-determination in Australia, the federal government is beginning to recognise Aboriginal people as active agents in shaping policy and knowledge. However, this recognition remains constrained by governance frameworks that continue to position the state as the central authority.

How outsourcing reinforces colonial governance

Outsourcing in Indigenous affairs undermines the development of better relations between First Nations and the state. Rather than producing meaningful partnerships, the state retains executive and financial authority while delegating accountability. Meanwhile, First Nations organisations remain subject to stringent top-down financial accountability mechanisms that undermine their capacity to be responsive and accountable to the community.

Under the guise of independence and impartiality, outsourcing instead contributes to the fragmentation and complexity of Indigenous affairs. It shows how colonial governance continues to operate today, particularly through routine operational practices. What is often presented as ‘business as usual’ can reinforce existing power structures and impede the renegotiation of authority over Indigenous lands.

Outsourcing and the power of government

Outsourcing emerged in the 1990s and flourished from 2000 onwards in line with the New Public Management (NPM) reforms. In Australia, this led to social policy environments in which contracting became pervasive. Regarding Indigenous affairs, NPM reforms involved the abolition of ATSIC and the subsequent ‘mainstreaming’ of Indigenous policy into existing social policy departments and a centralised whole-of-government approach. This included opening Indigenous program funding to competitive tender. Organisations with no links to or knowledge of Indigenous communities could then compete against Indigenous organisations for funding, in many cases undermining them.

Outsourcing in Indigenous affairs reflects and reinforces longstanding colonial power structures. By separating service delivery from decision-making authority, outsourcing allows governments to retain control over policy and funding while shifting responsibility for delivering services to other organisations.

This approach rests on two underlying assumptions:

  • Indigenous Peoples are not recognised as distinct political communities with collective rights grounded in their relationships to land

  • The state can continue to exercise unilateral control over Indigenous policy without negotiating or sharing authority.

These assumptions have implications for Indigenous self-determination. The allocation of funding intended for Indigenous communities to non-Indigenous organisations raises fundamental questions about whose rights, authority and priorities are recognised in the design and delivery of services. Rather than shifting power towards Indigenous communities, outsourcing can reproduce the very structures of control that self-determination seeks to challenge.

While outsourcing may make the state’s role in governing Indigenous Peoples less visible, governments continue to exercise political control through mechanisms such as setting policy priorities, establishing key performance indicators, managing contracts and ultimately retaining the power to fund or defund critical services.

The bottom line

Government outsourcing and related Indigenous procurement policies are often presented as promoting efficiency and competition. However, this framing can obscure their effects on Indigenous Peoples and communities they are intended to benefit. Prioritising market-based reforms or directing government spending to commercial entities do not necessarily strengthen Indigenous rights and capacity, which are the real drivers of Indigenous well-being.

The outsourcing of policy expertise to non-Indigenous commercial entities quickly leads to policy recommendations that work against Indigenous interests. Indigenous organisations, which are usually place-based and community-led, understand the complexities of decision-making and service delivery in place and remain the best and most durable source of policy expertise.

Want to read more?

Colonial logics in contemporary governance: The role of outsourcing in Indigenous affairs - Matthew Campbell, Eleanor Benson and Nikki Moodie, Australian Journal of Public Administration, October 2026

Read other Research Briefs on First Nations knowledge and policymaking below:

Stay connected to research that matters.

Join a growing community of public servants using evidence to inform decisions and strengthen public governance.